|Convicted financier Allen Stanford, who is serving 110 years in prison for his $7 billion Ponzi scheme, |
arrives at Federal Court in Houston for sentencing June 14, 2012.
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
U.S. Supreme Court Rules That Victims of Allen Sanford's Ponzi Scheme May Sue
Investors in Allen Stanford's $7 billion Ponzi scheme can sue to recoup losses from lawyers, insurance brokers and others who worked with the convicted swindler, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday.On a 7-2 vote, the court held that lawsuits filed in state courts can go forward. The majority said the ruling would not affect the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) ability to enforce securities law as some had feared.
Stanford's fraud involved the sale of bogus certificates of deposit by his Antigua-based Stanford International Bank. He is serving a 110-year prison sentence.
New York-based law firms Chadbourne & Parke LLP and Proskauer Rose LLP and insurance brokerage Willis Group Holdings Plc were sued by former Stanford investors. The investors also sued financial services firm SEI Investments Co and insurance company Bowen, Miclette & Britt.
"It's clear the justices understood that ruling for the defendants would create an immunity that Congress never imagined," said Tom Goldstein, a lawyer representing the former Stanford clients.
Representatives from the two law firms said that when the case returns to the lower court the defendants would move to dismiss the suit on other grounds.
Writing for the majority, Justice Stephen Breyer said the Securities Litigation Uniform Standards Act (SLUSA) did not prevent the state lawsuits from proceeding. The law says that state lawsuits are barred when the alleged misrepresentations are "in connection with" the purchase or sale of a covered security, which is defined as a security listed on a national exchange at the time the alleged unlawful conduct occurred.
As the defendants in the case were not selling securities traded on U.S. exchanges, "it is difficult to see why the federal securities laws would be - or should be - concerned with shielding such entities from lawsuits," Breyer wrote.
IMPACT ON SEC
The Obama administration, representing the SEC, had sided with the defendants to try to protect the agency's authority to pursue wide-ranging investigations.
The administration said the "in connection with" language in SLUSA that limits state court lawsuits mirrors language in federal law that gives broad authority of the SEC to pursue such misrepresentations.
Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in a dissenting opinion that the ruling would have a negative impact on the SEC because it "casts doubt on the applicability of federal securities law to cases of serious securities fraud." Kennedy was joined in dissent by Justice Samuel Alito.
Securities law experts backed the majority's view that the ruling was relatively narrow.
Donald Langevoort, a professor of law at Georgetown University, said he was "very surprised" the SEC tried to argue that a ruling in favor of the plaintiffs could diminish the government's enforcement powers.
"The opinion is imminently correct as a matter of common sense and legal policy," Langevoort said.
Charles Smith, of the law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP who represents clients before the SEC, said the agency would be comforted by the limited scope of the ruling.
"The decision is crafted in a way that is intended not to interfere with the SEC's enforcement authority," he said.
The SEC, via a spokesman, declined to comment.
The defendants had sought Supreme Court review after the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in March 2012 said the lawsuits brought under state laws by the former Stanford clients could go ahead.
The former Stanford clients are keen to pursue state law claims because the Supreme Court previously held that similar "aiding and abetting" claims cannot be made under federal law.
The class-action lawsuits filed by the former investors accused Thomas Sjoblom, a lawyer who worked at both law firms, of obstructing a SEC probe into Stanford, and sought to hold the other defendants responsible as well.
The cases are Chadbourne & Parke LLP v. Troice et al, U.S. Supreme Court. No. 12-79; Willis of Colorado Inc et al v. Troice et al, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 12-86; and Proskauer Rose LLP v. Troice et al, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 12-88.
(Reporting by Lawrence Hurley, additional reporting by Sarah N. Lynch; editing byHoward Goller, G Crosse and Amanda Kwan)
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Allen Stanford Sec Investigation, Allen Stanford, Obama Campaign, Barack Obama, Politics News
Obama isn't the only politician who has declined to return Stanford campaign contributions to help make Stanford's defrauded investors whole. A total of 39 candidates and committees have kept their campaign funds despite the pleas by the receiver.
Read More: Video, Standford Group, Stanford Group Charged, Allen Stanford, Sec Stanford Group, Reuters, Ponzi Scheme, Sec, Securities and Exchange Commission, Financial Regulation, Stanford Group Sec, Business News
Read More: Worst Financial Scandals, Financial Scandals, Allen Stanford, Worst Financial Scandals Death Match, Death Match, Enron, Charles Ponzi, Bernie Madoff, Nick Leeson, Libor Scandal, Subprime Cdos, Tom Petters, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Allen Stanford Sentenced, Allen Stanford Prison, Allen Stanford Ponzi Scheme, Allen Stanford Convicted, Allen Stanford, Allen Stanford Jail, Allen Stanford Years Jail, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Video, Allen Stanford, Allen-Stanford-Ponzi-Scheme, Business News, Allen Stanford Sec Investigation, Allen Stanford Fraud, Allen Stanford SEC, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Republican National Committee, John McCain, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, John Boehner, Allen Stanford, President Barack Obama, Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, President Obama, Ponzi Scheme, National Republican Senatorial Committee, Democratic National Committee, Democratic Party, Sir Allen Stanford, National Republican Congressional Committee, Barack Obama, Stanford International Bank, Antigua, Stanford Ponzi Scheme, Harry Reid, Republican Party, Robert Allen Stanford, Politics News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Video, Allen Stanford, Stanford Ponzi Scheme, Business News, Ponzi Scheme, Allen Stanford Conviction, Sir Allen Stanford, Allen Stanford Fraud, Business News
Read More: Stocks, Allen Stanford, Stock Market, Seven and a Half Things to Know, Dow, 7.5 Things, S&P 500, Video, Mark Gongloff Things to Know, Apple, Seven and a Half Things You Need to Know, Seven and a Half Things, Greece, Dow Jones Industrial Average, 7 1/2 Things, Things You Need to Know Today, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Business News, Allen Stanford Sec Investigation, Video, Allen Stanford Convicted, Allen Stanford Fraud, Allen Stanford, Allen-Stanford-Ponzi-Scheme, Business News
Read More: Watchdog Column, Regulatory Umbrella, Cruise Ship Regulations, SEC Accomplishments, Allen Stanford, Watchdog Blog, Fda, Volcker Rule, Cftc, Thewatchdog, SEC Financial Crisis, Regulations, Watchdog, Sec, Usda, John Engler, Business News
Read More: Financial Fraud, Video, Insider Trading, Freddie Mac, Hedge Fund Fraud, Hedge Funds, Allen Stanford, Lehman Brothers, Fannie Mae, Financial Crisis, Ponzi Scheme, Sec, Securities and Exchange Commission, Bernie Madoff, Bernie Madoff Ponzi Scheme, Business News
Read More: Allen Stanford Sec Investigation, Ponzi Scheme, Sec, Spencer Barasch, Spencer Barasch Investigation, Allen Stanford, Fbi, Business News
Read More: Business News, Stanford Financial Group, Ponzi Scheme Investigation, Allen Stanford Lawsuit, Securities and Exchange Commission, Allen Stanford, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Stanford Trial, Ponzi Scheme, Allen Stanford Anxiety, Bernie Madoff, Allen Stanford, Business News
Read More: Texas, Drug Addiction, Allen Stanford, Business News, Ponzi Scheme, Billionaires, Allen Stanford Drug, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Finra, Allen Stanford Brokers, Cruickshank, Danny Bogar, Allen Stanford, Wells Notices, Ponzi Scheme, Stanford Trial, Sec, Patrick, Allen Stanford Case, Business News
Read More: R. Allen Stanford, Lloyd's of London, Allen Stanford Witness, Allen Stanford, Business News
Read More: Portfolio, Ponzi, Sec, Madoff, Allen Stanford, Clawbacks, Money Management, Business News
Read More: SEC Goldman Sachs, Sec, SEC IG Report, Goldman Sachs Fraud, Securities and Exchange Commission, Allen Stanford, Eat the Press, Media News
Read More: Billionaires, Federal Prosecutors, David Hittner, Robert Bennett, Alan Dershowitz, Ponzi Scheme, Bernard Madoff, Allen Stanford, Texas Jail, White Collar Crime, Jail, Business News
Read More: Sessions, Allen Stanford, Pete Sessions Stanford, Pete Sessions Allen Stanford, Pete Sessions Email, Pete Sessions, Politics News
Read More: Raj Rajaratnam, Marc Dreier, White Collar Crime, Madoff, Allen Stanford, Blagojevich, Slidehuge, Robert Greenwood, Stephen Walsh, Slidepoll, Anthony Marshall, 2009 Crime, Bernie Madoff, Business News
Read More: Allen Stanford, Stanford Ponzi Scheme, Ponzi Scheme, Giant Ponzi Scheme, Charles Ponzi, Madoff Ponzi Scheme, Bernie Madoff Ponzi Scheme, Ponzi Schemes, Business News
Read More: Inter-American Economic Council, Gregory Meeks, Allen Stanford, New York City, New York, New York News